Hello,
I agree 100% with both of you, nobody "must" donate. A donation for what ?
If it is for the QSL card or the confirmation of QSO's I agree with: 1- QSL BUREAU, LOTW, E-QSL
Almost all DXpedition have their sponsors, who can be seen on every QSL cards.
We can see every time all the names of the big companies. They loan or give antennas, transceivers, filters, the QSL cards printing, etc, etc.
The only thing they have to pay individually is their personnal transportation/hotel/meals back »& forth.
like any personal trip you can do in your life. Playing radio is an extra, like any activities you can do in a regular trip.
Finally for them it is only a "SPECIAL" Holiday, which cost a lot of money,mainly due to the high cost of transportation but My feelings, very simply, about this issue fall along the lines of how I manage my personal finances. If I can't afford it, I don't go. No-one is "obligated" to insure that my expedition is funded. That said, I have no issue with someone asking me to help defray their costs, e.g., I am paying for my expedition.
If they want to lower their costs, there are different simple things they can do, and I'm sure no one else want to go without their Amplifier!!, If you have an amplifier, you need generators, Gerry can full of gas,
Imagine the cost of transportation just for these.
They forgot completly, that being close to salt water, it is 10 dB gain, ok ? the callsign, of the island, is another 10 dB gain, and if an operator is a YL, it is another 10 +++ dB gain.
Now, a must to read: N1DG - DXpetition Costs - Dayton Ohio 2012 or
TRAVERSING A MONEY STORM WHEN PLANNING A DXPEDITION BY: N1DG, DON GREENBAUM 19 MAY 2012
It is very interesting and instructive to read at:
http://dx-world.net/2012/dxpedition-costs/ My feelings, very simply, about this issue fall along the lines of how I manage my personal finances. If I can't afford it, I don't go there. No-one is "obligated" to insure that my DXexpedition is funded. That said, I have no issue with someone asking me to help defray their costs, e.g., I am paying for my expedition,
Michel VE2TH QRP...\ more to come